“Do the laws of the Church in general, and those of religious life in particular, compromise a person’s freedom?

Early in 2017, a young Arts student contacted us via our website with a query. She herself was a practicing Catholic, but was aware that many of her peers were  giving up the practice  of their faith, and particularly, Sunday Mass. She wondered if this was because the Church had put down so many rules and regulations that they were put off for fear of losing (?) their personal freedom.  This led her to wonder what we, as cloistered nuns, felt about freedom.  What follows is the reply she was offered.

Before speaking about freedom for enclosed nuns, Let us look first at how anyone might understand the word or concept of “freedom”, what it actually means. I put forward a few ideas:

True freedom is an interior quality, especially indicating freedom from evil, from error, from fear, and in a positive sense, it includes an inclination towards  what is true and good. It is only in a very immature and irrational sense it might be supposed to mean “doing whatever I want!” Suppose, for example, that someone wants to play football- or any other sport, for that matter,- and decides to scrap all the rules because they inhibit  one’s freedom,  what, then ,is left of an intelligible game?

To suppose that “Religion”  (or ,if you like, “God”) limits our individual  freedom , is I fear, often the result of very inadequate education ! Could I suggest that one looks at the Church’s moral or doctrinal teaching as something like “The Maker’s Instructions”, on how to understand and get the most out of our lives. Have you ever bought a rather special and expensive piece of equipment – perhaps a camera,  or a laptop,  or a  food-processor? There is usually a handbook to introduce you to the capacity of your new product, which would guide you on how to make the most of it, and probably have a  few cautions or even prohibitions, such as:” Don’t put your food-processor into the dishwasher or  put oil in your laptop, or drop your camera on a stone floor.” There are no penalties for not observing these cautions- only the ruin of your new  product! If we want  to make the most of any aspect of our personal lives, to attain the maximum of happiness, we do well to take these “Maker’s Instructions” seriously. The most basic code is the 10 Commandments, which feature in some form or other almost world-wide, ensuring that we respect the aspirations of everyone else, not just our own! In the New Testament, Jesus even reduces all  these laws to just two: Loving God above all else, and loving our neighbour as ourselves. The Catholic Church hasn’t actually created new  laws, but has given a few guidelines on how to respond to the basic ones.

It is said  that young people are falling away from going to Mass.  No doubt they feel they are exercising an adult choice – but do they also choose not to eat any nourishing food,  or take any other steps to maintain their health and well-being, just because they  used to have to take what Mum provided when they were little? Nobody is going to take a whip and force them to go to Mass, but  because they have, perhaps, never been taught  what an incredible richness lies in the whole Sacramental life of the Church,  they are starving themselves,  doing without  an incredibly life-enhancing Gift  from God…. Is this “freedom” ? or just an ignorance that sees no further  than maybe the hymns or the sermons, and finds them boring? If we had any idea of what the Mass really is, we would queue up and pay to attend !

NOW to get to the heart of your question, about how do nuns in an enclosed convent  feel about freedom? I have tried to suggest that freedom is basically wanting to  seek and find  what is truest  and best in all that life offers us. The  purpose of a cloistered convent  is  to provide the  best  opportunity to  focus  on  loving, – and being loved by, God, in a deeply  personal way. St John says: ”God is Love”. What else do we learn about Him? As a rather formal response, one can say: “God is  the Supreme Spirit, who alone exists of Himself, and  is  infinite in all perfections”. … all beauty, all goodness, all tenderness, all everything  we want and need Him to be. There is nothing about a judgemental Authority Figure here. A vocation to the life of a cloistered nun  is a sense of being  personally invited to a lifelong intimate friendship with Him. I do not  pretend that  accepting this invitation  is easy, as in order to accept all that God offers we have to give  over everything to Him, It takes time and courage  to learn how to give up our petty littleness, and we have to do this freely and willingly. Anyone can do this, anywhere, but doing it in a cloistered Monastery means that we have a huge amount of support and encouragement  from the sisters who live with us.  The fact that life in a convent is directed from  morning to night  by rules and customs surprisingly enough does not impinge on our free consent  to them. As a kind of illustration, if I was a keen musician, and wanted to play in a prestigious  orchestra, I would not feel that having to study carefully, and follow  precisely a musical score and the directions  of the  conductor was limiting  my freedom  of expression, but rather that it would be essential in helping me to be  part of something  much greater that my  individual self. Following the Rules of religious life is actually enormously liberating, so I think that is how I, and my companions accept it.

Sr Mary of St Philip (Notting Hill)